Carter Report calls on health technology to help save NHS billions

Many of us aspire to be the best we can be, and Labour peer Lord Carter of Coles has set out a series of recommendations on how the NHS can achieve similar aspirations with the support of health technology in his much-vaunted report into NHS productivity and efficiency.

Operational productivity and performance in English NHS acute hospitals: Unwarranted variations is the compelling result of the peer’s work with 32 English trusts on identifying areas of excellence and areas for improvement. By taking note of the recommendations it contains, the report estimates that the NHS could save £5bn every year.

Health technology has a crucial part to play, and Lord Carter has called for all NHS trusts to have key digital information systems in place, “fully integrated and utilised by October 2018, and NHS Improvement should ensure this happens through the use of ‘meaningful use’ standards and incentives.”

The systems are e-rostering, e-prescribing, patient-level costing and accounting systems, e-catalogue and inventory systems for procurement, RFID systems where appropriate, and electronic health records. Some parallels exist with the McKinsey report into systems that have the potential to save the NHS money, as can be found on page 9 of the presentation published by Could these be the succcessors to the Clinical Five that the NHS was encouraged to adopt?

Meaningful use required for health technology

The report recommends that the NHS Improvement body, due to be set up in April 2016, take the lead by setting the standards for ‘meaningful use’ of such systems and incentivising trusts to achieve them.

Carter takes the definition of ‘meaningful use’ from the The American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009, which specified three main components of ‘meaningful use’:

  • the use of a certified electronic health record (EHR) in a meaningful manner
  • the electronic exchange of health information to improve quality of health care
  • the use of certified EHR technology to submit clinical quality and other measures.

For the report, ‘meaningful use’ means providers need to show they’re using certified EHR technology in ways that can be measured significantly in quality and in quantity. Financial penalties could be put in place if such standards cannot be met.

In the US, where this term originates, the Meaningful Use program (sic) has been declared ‘dead’, and a successor programme is now planned.

On finances, Carter asks that the Department of Health “should make some of the Spending Review investment for IT available for trusts to meet these standards, with a suitable ‘meaningful use’ clause embedded in contracts.” Boards will be held accountable to ensure that IT systems are used to their full potential. It will be interesting to see how that one plays out! Hopefully Microsoft will not be on the phone to say that people are not using the Tasks element of Outlook properly…

However the sentiment is right. Lord Carter and his team were “struck by the immaturity of trusts’ use of such technology from e-rostering systems, e-prescribing and basic electronic catalogues for procurement”. So there is the chance to do more, but hopefully trusts will make choices that do make the most of the technology on offer.

Carter does recognise that data, interoperability and governance are all key to the appropriate use of technology. He states: “To truly performance manage quality and efficiency on a regular basis, seamless real-time data is needed, which in turn requires investment in interoperable information technology.”

Interoperability and data are key

The death knell is sounded for ‘data-huggers’ that do not release information to others involved in healthcare.

“Data, if it exists, currently resides in independent pockets, sometimes guarded by data owners. This cannot continue. The best performing hospital systems around the world have real-time data at their fingertips enabling them to make decisions on a daily, weekly, monthly basis to improve performance. It’s long been said that the NHS, as a national system, has a huge opportunity to join up this data across boundaries but we continue to struggle to make this happen.”

Recommendation 8 has implications for technology projects. It states that “NHS Improvement and NHS England should establish joint clinical governance by April 2016 to set standards of best practice for all specialties, which will analyse and produce assessments of clinical variation, so that unwarranted variation is reduced, quality outcomes improve, the performance of specialist medical teams is assessed according to how well they meet the needs of patients and efficiency and productivity increase along the entire care pathway.”

Data will be an essential part of this process. NHS Improvement is set an immediate deadline in support, to bring “all existing clinical registries and data source feeds into its new structure in order to establish National and Local dashboards for each clinical specialty, to enable real time assessment of clinical performance, to identify and drive the required changes by July 2016.”

The recommendation also promotes “the innovative use of system-wide information and communications technologies approved by the HSCIC that support the clinical processes, with the aim of improving the quality, efficiency and safety of the care delivered.” It will be interesting to hear more about this.

The report is wide-ranging, and looks at the need for greater collaboration and the barrier presented by delayed transfers of care. Technology can help here, with NHS Improvement charged with an online portal to share good practice. Integrated systems can help coordinate care across the patient pathway.

The Carter report recognises that the NHS is the best value healthcare system in the world. But it could do better. We all could, I guess, if we had the time, money and support. Will the NHS get the support it needs to carry out these changes?

Let us hope that perilous finances do not make these recommendations last as long as a New Year’s resolution.    

Further information
Do read the executive summary of the report on the DH website. The NHS Confederation has presented a good summary of the report and its recommendations, and the HSJ focuses on the drive for wider use of technology.

The following two tabs change content below.

Rob Benson

Senior Communications Consultant
Rob has worked in marketing and digital roles for over 15 years, in a career spanning the NHS, academia and the private sector.

With a passion for creative ideas and their practical application, Rob is committed to delivering excellence for his clients through a full understanding of their needs and aspirations.

He has worked across technical and communication roles with organisations including BT and the Department of Health, and has run his own marketing consultancy business. His healthcare experience covers web and knowledge management for a primary care trust and commissioning support unit, and includes digital consultancy for the national end of life care workstream.

In addition, his other core skills include marketing and communications, business planning, copywriting, training, social media, and market research.

“Healthcare depends on excellent intelligence and effective communication. Great ideas and sensible advice can get lost if they are not presented in the right way, and are reaching the right people.

“This is where marketing concepts and practices can help. Shaping services to meet people’s needs and aspirations is core to both healthcare and marketing professions. Bringing the two together can have a positive impact on everyone’s experience, and it is a privilege to work with colleagues and clients who deliver this in a dynamic and exciting field.”
A little bit about Rob:
  • Yorkshire born Rob combines a love of rugby, cricket and golf with an active interest in real ale and TV detective shows.
  • Currently living in Birmingham, Rob is a father, stepfather and grandfather, and spends most of the year saving up for birthdays and Christmas.
  • Other interests including reading, walking, art and travel.

Want more articles like this one?

Our free newsletter drops into your inbox every Friday to bring you...
  • Industry news
  • Essential analysis
  • Unmissable interviews
  • HM blog posts, tips and advice

Sign up:

Highland Marketing Ltd will use the information you provide on this form to send you our newsletter. Additionally, please let us know if you would like to hear from us about:

Read more information about our privacy practices. By clicking to subscribe below, you agree that we may process your information in accordance with these terms.